Look at these data derived from Piagetian-type interviews. Do textbooks and state curriculum guidelines ever consider the limited thinking skills of children?

when studies have been done thruout the country they show that th majority of students do not have the rational problem solving powers to understand the concepts that are attempting to be taught. This study comes from Renner ( dr. leyden's teacher one summer in Oklahoma )

piagetian interview results -- oklahoma
grade tested concrete transition formal
7th 96 kids 80 13 3
8th 108 kids 83 19 6
9th 94 kids 77 5 9
10th 94 kids 68 16 10
11th 99 kids 70 17 12
12th 97 kids 64 15 18


this data came from a teacher in colorado -- but i don't know it's original source

students reaching various piagetian stages
age pre-op concrete onset concrete mature formal onset formal mature
5 85% 15% 0 0 0
6 60% 35% 5% 0 0
7 35% 55% 10% 0 0
8 25% 55% 20% 0 0
9 15% 55% 30% 0 0
10 12% 52% 35% 1% 0
11 6% 49% 40% 5% 0
12 5% 32% 51% 12% 0
13 2% 34% 44% 14% 6%
14 1% 32% 43% 15% 9%
15 1% 14% 53% 19% 13%
16 1% 15% 54% 17% 13%
17 3% 19% 47% 19% 12%
18 1% 15% 50% 15% 19%

bottom line:
just because kids have big bodies -- doesn't insure that their thinking skills are "big" 9/28s/96